Japanese | English

トップページへ戻る

詳細

   
フルテキストURLC070007000008.pdf ( 745.1KB ) 公開日 2010-12-10
タイトル現代の「人格」理論 : 「パーソン論」に対する一注釈
タイトルヨミゲンダイ ノ ジンカク リロン パーソンロン ニ タイスル イチチュウシャク
タイトル別表記A comment on the concept of `person' in bioethics
作成者加藤, 和哉
作成者ヨミカトウ, カズヤ
作成者別表記Kato, Kazuya
内容記述(抄録等)In this essay I argued the concept of person which underlies some ethical issues today, such as moral justification of abortion, euthanasia of heavily disabled infants, etc. Michael Tooley, for example, argued that only those self-conscious are the ‘person' who has full moral right to live. The argument has received much criticism (in Japan) that it presupposes a very narrow idea of a human being, namely person as rational self-conscious agent, which comes from John Locke or Immanuel Kant. The criticism on the other hand emphasizes the relational aspect of a human being and argues that, even if a fetus itself is not a ‘person', he/she is for some others, such as his/her parents, a human being which must be morally protected. 1 point out that the ‘relational aspect' of a human being is not supposed to consist in that being itself, but only in the concrete concern that others have to that being, because what the being itself is does not matter there. As a result, the anti-personal theory seems only to accept the case where a human being has nobody to have a concrete relation to him/her or the case where a human being is not treated as such by others. I hint at a more' fundamental problem that there is no other way to talk about a human being itself than as a self-conscious agent.
本文言語jpn
資料タイプtext
ファイル形式application/pdf
出版者山口大学哲学研究会
出版者ヨミヤマグチ ダイガク テツガク ケンキュウカイ
NII資料タイプ紀要論文
ISSN0919-357X
NCIDAN10403441
学内刊行物(紀要等)山口大学哲学研究
掲載誌名山口大学哲学研究
掲載誌名別表記The philosophical studies of Yamaguchi University
7
開始ページ149
終了ページ161
発行日1998
著者版/出版社版出版社版
リポジトリIDC070007000008
地域区分山口大学
URIhttp://www.lib.yamaguchi-u.ac.jp/yunoca/handle/C070007000008